Skip to content
Sunstar Graphics Brochures
  1. Home
  2. Knowledge
  3. Screen printing vs digital printing for industrial parts
Back to Knowledge

Guide

Screen printing vs digital printing: which process fits industrial parts

Screen printing is the better process for volume production, for thick or opaque ink films and for functional inks such as silver, carbon and glass enamel. Digital printing is better for short runs, many design versions and variable data. It is common to use digital for samples and screen printing for production.

How the two processes differ

In screen printing, a squeegee pushes ink through a mesh stencil onto the part. Each colour or layer needs its own screen. The mesh and the stencil set how much ink goes down, so the ink film can be made thin or thick as the job needs.

In digital printing, inkjet heads place very small drops of ink straight from the file. There is no screen to make. The ink has to be thin enough, and its particles small enough, to pass through the nozzles. Most industrial inkjet printers use UV-cured inks.

Screen and digital compared

Screen printingDigital (inkjet) printing
SetupOne screen for each colour or layerNo screens. Prints from the file
Cost per pieceFalls as the run gets longerAbout the same at any quantity
Ink filmThick. Typically 5 to 30 microns in one pass, more with coarse meshThin. Built up with extra passes
Ink typesUV, solvent, conductive, dielectric, ceramic, adhesive, textureInks made for the print head, mainly colour inks
ColourMixed spot colours, opaque white, metallicsProcess colour from a fixed ink set
Variable dataThe same image on every sheetEvery piece can be different

Where screen printing is the right process

Screen printing is the right process for the work listed below. The ink film depends on the mesh and the ink, so check the ink maker's data sheet for the recommended mesh and deposit.

  • Functional layers: silver and carbon circuits, dielectric, printed heaters and sensors, which need a thick and even film
  • Opaque white and dense black on clear polycarbonate and polyester, for backlit dials and overlays
  • Solid bands and borders of glass enamel on appliance and automotive glass at production speed
  • Texture, hard coat, spot UV and printed adhesive
  • Long runs of the same part, such as decals, labels and nameplates
  • Brand colours matched with a mixed spot colour, and prints that have to last outdoors

Where digital printing is the right process

Digital printing has no screen to make, so a new design can go to print very quickly. The cost per piece stays about the same, so the advantage fades as the quantity rises. It suits:

  • Prototypes and samples, before screens are made
  • Short runs and many versions of one design
  • Serial numbers, barcodes and other variable data
  • Photographic images with many colours in one pass

Using both in one plant

The two processes are often combined. A nameplate maker may screen print the solid colours and the protective coat, then add a serial number digitally. A membrane switch maker may proof an overlay digitally and screen print the production run.

The quantity at which screen printing becomes cheaper depends on the part, the number of colours and the ink. Work it out from the screen cost, the setup time and the ink cost per piece.

Computer-to-screen (CTS) imaging also shortens screen printing setup. The screen is imaged straight from the file without a film positive, so a new job reaches the press sooner.

What Sunstar supplies

Sunstar Graphics supplies industrial screen printing machinery in India: ATMA flatbed and application-specific printers, SPS stop-cylinder presses, Lingtie roll-to-roll presses, Grünig screen making machines, SignTronic CTS systems, Luen Cheong IR and UV dryers and RKS squeegees. Sunstar is the exclusive distributor for these brands and also supplies Kuroki squeegees from Taiwan. It installs, trains and services from Mumbai, across India.

If your parts need thick, opaque or functional ink films in volume, send an enquiry with your material, print size and output per hour. Sunstar replies within one working day, and you can ask for machine options and Indian pricing.

Machines for this

Supplied in India by Sunstar.

FAQ

Short answers

Is screen printing better than digital printing for industrial parts?

For volume production and for thick, opaque or functional ink films, yes. Digital printing is better for short runs, samples and variable data.

Can digital printing replace screen printing for membrane switches?

Digital printing can do the colour graphics of an overlay in short runs. The silver, carbon and dielectric circuit layers are screen printed, because they need a thick and even ink film.

Which is cheaper, screen printing or digital printing?

Digital printing is cheaper for small quantities because there are no screens to make. Screen printing becomes cheaper per piece as the run gets longer.

Why is screen printing still used in industry?

It lays down a thicker ink film than other printing processes and works with a very wide range of inks, including conductive, ceramic and adhesive inks.

Inquiry

Tell Sunstar what you print.

An engineer replies within one working day with machine options and Indian pricing.

0 machines